The Toastmaster Electric Sandwich Maker
Thursday, May 31st, 2007Years ago I found myself in Bali, chilling. I visited every corner of that island, from the artist friendly towns in the mountains to the beaches and smaller islands a few miles off the coast. One thing that I found to be consistent during that whole trip was the appearance of a ‘jaffle’ on most menus.
Not knowing what it really was, I went ahead and ordered one. How bad could something be if the varieties included ham/cheese or banana/honey (among others). A ‘jaffle’ as it turned out was a grilled, sealed sandwich, and, delicious. At one bed and breakfast I managed to spy one of the cooks making one. The thing was an iron round press on a long handle that sat over an open fire. Much like this thing:
![]()
Minus the embossed logo in the sandwich and the round shape (the ones in Bali were square) and add a bit more of a primative look.
Anyhow, the point I am trying to make is that I enjoyed the hell out of those sandwiches enough to make me want to recreate them back home.
Once I got back to the states, the closest thing I could find to make some jaffles was the Toastmaster Sandwich maker, which I quickly picked up and put to use. First off, the name itself is a misnomer as the thing does not make the sandwich for you, but simply grill the thing. Let’s be real here. Aside from that little nitpit, I found some key differences - once being the seam in the middle that split/seals the single sandwich in two pieces. That split center really limits the amount of ingredients per sandwich. Sealing it off like that allows for less inside. Additionally, if you want to put anything that does not separate by heat alone, say, ham, then you have to make sure that you do not intersect that seam, otherwise you are still going to have to pull out a knife.
![]()
Second issue is that is it not big enough for a standard slice of bread, which means that you have to prep the bread first and slice off the crusts. Major pain in the ass when all you want to do is slap some bread, cheese and ham in the thing. Also, if you accidentally cut the bread too small, you screw up your sealing.
Which brings me to the last problem with this device. Sealing. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn’t. It all depends on the ratio of bread surface area : ingredients. If you do not have a perfect ratio, be prepared to have a poorly put together sandwich.
Overall, I do not recommend this item as it has too many rules to stick to. I wish I had seen the Diablo stovetop sandwich maker before getting this Toastmaster, but such is life before high-speed wireless. Maybe someday I will check the Diablo out, but for now, a pan works just fine.
Status: Used about 4 times over 6 years. Eventually given to a friend, where I am positive it remains dormant in her cupboard.

